Our Summer Issue


  • The Summer PCJ includes articles on libraries at the heart of our communities; using benchmarks & indicators to measure plan implementation; public speaking tips for commissioners -- and much more. Due out: July 27th.

Receive Email Updates

  • Receive one to two emails a month with helpful information about: our monthly specials; updates on our blog reports; and summaries of the content of new issues of the Planning Commissioners Journal.

Keep Posted:


Circle the USA Reports: 1st Leg Mar 30 - Apr 10

Future Segments

  • Leg 3: Sept. 8-17, 2009
    Chicago area, and portions of Illinois, Iowa, and Wisconsin
    -- details to be posted in early August
Share/Save/Bookmark

T.G.I.F.

  • Head into the weekend on the right foot. Enjoy a short video (10 minutes or less) on the PlannersWeb

Join Us On


  • If you're a Facebook member, just search for Planning Commissioners Journal.

Connect with Our Editor

  • View Wayne Senville's profile on LinkedIn
    email: pcjoffice@gmail.com

Route 50 trip

« Now Available: Our Spring Issue | Main | Is there a Belisha Beacon in Your Neighborhood? »

May 22, 2008

What's Round, Weighs 250 Pounds ...

From PCJ Editor Wayne Senville:

What's round, weighs 250 pounds, and plays a vital role in our cities and towns? Want another hint? It can be found just about everywhere you walk or drive. If you haven't guessed (or peeked at the photos), I'm talking about the ubiquitous manhole cover.

Yet it's worth giving them a moment's thought. Consider that besides being functional parts of a city's infrastructure, they can also be works of art. Certainly that's the case throughout Japan, where cities have their own distinctive manhole cover designs, and in other countries as well.

Manhole_japan_arimashi_4 Manhole_japan_maizurushi_5

Manhole_israel2 The top two manhole covers above are from Japan. Photos of many more of the remarkable Japanese manhole covers can be viewed on Flickr. See also the blog post, Street Art & Railway Melodies of Japan. I took the photo of the cover on the left in Acre, Israel (north of Haifa).

Even in the U.S., people are recognzing that manhole covers can add a bit of "art" underfoot. Denver, Colorado's Lower Downtown Historic District uses a quite distinctive manhole cover design (below left). And consider this comment from Ketchum, Idaho: "How can we make art part of our infrastructure?" asked Claudia McCain, a member of the Wood River Arts Alliance ... Manhole_denver_co_2"Manhole covers, sidewalks, grates -- they can be made more attractive, exciting and inviting." See "Ketchum's Creativity Creates a Stir" (Idaho Mountain Express, March 21, 2007).

But also consider that manhole covers and other street gratings have a long and proud heritage, dating back to the middle of the 1870s. You might have a part of the 19th century in your own city or town.

Manhole_sewer_dc_2Take a look, for example, at this 1895 Sewer Dept. manhole I came across while visiting the Capitol Hill neighborhood in Washington, D.C.

As Rob Goodspeed notes in a posting about D.C.'s manhole covers and grates, "beauty aside, to the informed reader manholes can tell a story about the history and function of the modern city."

Manhole_worker_chillicothe_2

Above: at work in Chillicothe, Ohio.

Manhole_emporia_kansas Many of the manhole covers on our streets come from U.S. companies like the Wisconsin-based Neenah Foundry or The Ford Meter Box Company in Wabash, Indiana.

But like so much else manufactured, a growing proportion of our manhole covers and and other street gratings are now being manufactured overseas and shipped here. India is perhaps the hot spot for these products.

Want to see what an Indian manhole factory looks like? Take a look at some amazing photos taken by photojournalist J. Adam Huggins for an article in The New York Times ("New York Manhole Covers, Forged Barefoot in India" Nov. 27, 2007). Be sure to view the "media" slideshow (scroll down a bit on the left side of the Times article).

Manhole_kansas_city_sewer_2 I came across this India-made cover in Kansas City, Missouri.

Want to know more about manholes? Interested in becoming a "drainspotter"? One treasure-trove of information and illustrations is Mimi and Robert Melnick's Manhole Covers (MIT Press, 1994).

As Mimi Melnick tells it, "covers speak to us through their identifying labels. They tell stories of water and power, they whisper steam, they shout out the names of the foundries that cast them."

But their design is also eminently practical. Ever wonder why manhole covers are round? Melnick explains that "Round covers are easier to machine accurately, one reason for the popularity of that shape. Round manhole covers are also preferred because they won't fall into the manholes, and because, once removed, they can be rolled rather than lifted repeatedly." But there's always that darn exception: in Manchester, New Hampshire, manhole covers are apparently triangular. But then, they're just stubborn, independent-minded folks in the Granite State!

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341bf9ae53ef00e551cd9f7a8834

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference What's Round, Weighs 250 Pounds ...:

Comments

Special Offers

  • Check for current special offers from the Planning Commissioners Journal -- you can find big savings. New special offer posted every month -- sign up for our email reminders below.

Resource Pages

Search PCJ Articles by Keyword

Our Two Best Selling Publications

Editor's Picks

Review Draft PCJ Articles

Planning Law


  • Our Taking a Closer Look: Planning Law publication is an excellent introduction to a wide range of legal issues. Take a look at its contents (click on the cover image above) -- order online for quick delivery by 1st class mail.

Be Informed

Contact info.

  • Planning Comm'rs Journal, P.O. Box 4295, Burlington, VT 05406 / 802-864-9083 pcjoffice@gmail.com

Copyright

  • Much of the graphics and text posted on our site is copyright protected by the Planning Commissioners Journal. Please email us with any questions about use of materials.

Map of the Week